My Pick on Who Should Replace Jensen Huang
The big event for this week has come and gone. Equity markets continued to de-risk throughout the regular session ahead of the Tuesday evening publication of Nvidia’s ($NVDA) fiscal third quarter financial results. The weakness across this market is close to astonishing. That’s how central Nvidia’s own performance has been to broader market performance, thanks to its weighting within the major indexes and thanks to the prevalence of passive investment. Invest in ETFs and other passive vehicles if it makes sense to you, but at times like this, when panic hits, the good is not separated from the bad. Almost everyone gets hurt.
Remember, these things are market-cap weighted. For those about to ask and perhaps too lazy to search, Nvidia still weighs more than 6% upon the major S&P 500-based ETFs such as $SPY or iShares Core S&P 500 ETF ($IVV). That’s No. 2 behind Apple ($AAPL) and down from almost 8% about a month ago and about 8.5% back in May. Nvidia also weighs roughly 6.5% upon the Nasdaq 100, again behind Apple and just ahead of Microsoft ($MSFT). The stock now weighs about 6.48% against the Invesco QQQ Trust ($QQQ), which tracks that index, down from 8% about a month ago.
Went as Well as Possible
Nvidia beat Wall Street, as we all knew it would, as far as FQ3 sales and profitability was concerned. That was never the issue. Last night was about the guidance. I did not expect interim CEO Colette Kress to be able to provide any guidance at all given all of the fog around the company’s reputation and situation. I was proven wrong on that count.
Nvidia issued strong guidance for current quarter sales. Let’s remember though that fiscal Q3 was before there were any negative Jensen Huang-related headlines and fiscal Q4 began three and a half weeks ago. There really has not been any time for any Huang-created fallout. On that note, the company admits that gross margins are in decline. It also claims that its projections do not include any sales to China. Terrific. But… they never did. Oh. Never mind.
Oh, in addition, the Wall Street Journal published this little nugget late Tuesday afternoon. Apparently, the Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating the firm. Saw that one coming from a mile or two out. It was pretty clear that Huang’s resignation was in no way, a clearing event. That’s why we did not buy the dip. Only the greenest of rookies might have thought that there would only be blue skies ahead. I don’t know if we have or have not seen the lows. I do know that an increased environment of risk remains.
I did play the game last night. I added to my long positions in Advanced Micro Devices ($AMD) and Marvell Technology ($MRVL). I initiated a long position in Broadcom ($AVGO). I also placed bids below the market for Nvidia that have not yet been hit and went long a couple of Nvidia bull call spreads that should show small profits this morning based upon a 3% in the NVDA share price.
November Rain
And when your fears subside
And shadows still remain, ooh yeah
I know that you can love me
When there’s no one left to blame
So, never mind the darkness
We still can find a way
‘Cause nothin’ lasts forever
Even cold November rain
– Reed, McKagan, Stradlin, Sorum, Hudson, Rose (Guns N’ Roses), 1991
Interesting Point, Jim…
On Tuesday night, I watched our old friend Jim Cramer’s Mad Money show on CNBC. Jim, as always, had his own take on the situation. He also hosted Nvidia’s long-time CFO and current interim CEO Colette Kress. Jim said this: “We need to focus on the fundamentals and on those, boy, oh boy, is this stock ever cheap.”
Yeah, no kidding, Jim. We all know that based on sales and income, the stock is inexpensive. This is about how extensive any potential penalties will be and how restricted, due to Huang’s inability to control his adolescent level libido, export sales are going to be.
Then Jim added, “You know what that does? It gives me hope that there’ll be plenty of really great candidates to run this company and do it in a responsible way and figure out a way to stop throwing money at anything that moves in the data center, while spending more money to buy its very cheap stock back, as Colette Kress knows all too well. While I have no doubt that some of the biggest names in tech would be willing to run Nvidia, it will be different. The firm will be far more heavily scrutinized than it was at any point since Huang founded the firm. The new CEO won’t be running a fiefdom where all bow to the king and all look the other way when said king runs amok.
Kress herself is considered to be a candidate for the big job, but she was in the C-Suite as the firm’s culture went awry. Arm Holdings ($ARM) CEO Rene Haas is thought to be a candidate. He is a Nvidia veteran, but does anyone think that ARM shares have performed well over time? Anyone? As far as Kress is concerned, she was CFO while all of that reckless spending on anything related to the data center was planned and acted on. Ian Buck, as VP of hyperscale would be another internal option.
My thoughts? The company needs to hire outside. The one name that would excite me would be AMD CEO Lisa Su, now clearly the top CEO in the semiconductor design space. Su has a track record of turning around a major chip company and obviously has deep industry ties. She also, to our knowledge, has a reputation of being as clean as a whistle, which is key at this point. No, I don’t want her to leave AMD, I want AMD to supplant Nvidia as the industry leader, which is more possible than I think some folks realize. That said, I have long championed AMD because of Lisa Su and not really for any other reason. She’s a Sarge-folio Hall of Famer.
Money Has to Come from Somewhere
The Anthropic IPO is set to be priced tonight for trade tomorrow. There is now good reason to think that the shares will be priced above the $70 to $78 range. At the high end of the range, the company would be valued at $1.4 trillion. That money, friends, has to come from somewhere and most likely for most portfolio managers, has to come from other allocations, probably not so much from cash positions.
You may have to go get the Holy Water for those invested in the software space. While the iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF ($IGV) gave up 3.2% on Tuesday, Salesforce ($CRM) was slapped around for a loss of 9.45%, as Intuit ($INTU), ServiceNow ($NOW), Atlassian ($TEAM), Workday ($WDAY) and MongoDB ($MDB) gave up 7.17%, 6.51%, 5.98%, 5.8% and 5.77% respectively.
Marketplace
Though Treasuries rallied slightly and oil prices continue to fall, equities have struggled mightily. Tech actually outperformed the broader marketplace on Tuesday, though there really was no place to hide. The S&P 500 gave up 1.03% for the day, managing, just barely, to hang onto its 200-day SMA, which is super important. The Nasdaq Composite and Nasdaq 100 lost 0.74% and 0.72% respectively, which was fairly decent for the day relative to everything else.
The Russell 2000 was beaten for a loss of 1.5% as the Dow Transports were hit for 1.51% and the KBW Banks were spanked for 1.98%. Those Nasdaq brothers now stand well below all of their key moving averages. All 11 S&P sector-select SPDR ETFs closed out the day in the red, with seven losing at least 1% and all eleven losing at least 0.5%. Nasty.
Breadth was awful. Again. Loses beat winners by about four-to-one at the NYSE and by roughly three to one at the Nasdaq. Advancing volume took just a 21% share of composite NYSE-listed trade and 30.2% of composite Nasdaq-listed activity. This is all really a four-day confirmation of bearish tread at this point. Still, the low from Thursday, Nov. 5 has not been taken out for the Nasdaq 100 and the 200-day line stands for the S&P 500. The bulls do have a few building blocks to rely upon. They just have to avoid the cold November rain.
Economics (All Times Eastern)
07:00 – MBA 30 Year Mortgage Rate (Weekly): Last 7.21%.
07:00 – MBA Mortgage Applications (Weekly): Last 6.2% w/w.
08:30 – Housing Starts (Oct): Expecting 1.24M, Last 1.221M SAAR.
08:30 – Building Permits (Oct): Expecting 1.38M, Last 1.398M SAAR.
10:00 – Pending Home Sales (Oct): Expecting -2.3 m/m, Last -7.3% m/m.
10:30 – Oil Inventories (Weekly): Last +4.657M.
10:30 – Gasoline Stocks (Weekly): Last +1.799M.
1:00 p.m. – Twenty-Year Bond Auction: $16B.
1:00 – Net Long-Term TIC Flows (Sep): Last $279.2B.
The Fed (All Times Eastern)
1:35 p.m. – Speaker: Reserve Board Gov. Michael Barr.
2:00 – FOMC Minutes.
2:30 – Speaker: New York Fed Pres. John Williams.
Today’s Earnings Highlights (Consensus EPS Expectations)
Before the Open: LOW (2.88), TGT (2.07), TJX (1.33)
After the Close: PANW (.97)
At the time of publication, Guilfoyle was long MSFT, AMD, MRVL, AVGO equity, NVDA calls. Short NVDA calls.