Doug Kass is a world-renowned hedge fund manager with decades of experience and success navigating through some of the most turbulent periods in market history. He is known for his time-tested analytical skills and ability to look past the current noise and herd mentality.
On TheStreet Pro, Kass provides frequent market commentary and investing ideas for active investors throughout each trading day in Doug’s Daily Diary. He also serves as president of Seabreeze Partners Management Inc. Previously, he served as a senior manager at Omega Advisors, a $6 billion investment partnership. He co-authored a book with Ralph Nader and the Center for the Study of Responsive Law called “Citibank: The Ralph Nader Report” and can be found as a guest host on CNBC's "Squawk Box."
A Note from Doug: Current strategies and actionable trade ideas -- all on one dynamic platform built exclusively for active trades. From sudden sell-offs to sudden spikes, TheStreet Pro arms you with crucial analysis -- at a rapid fire, professional pace -- to help you make sound trading decisions -- every day, every hour, and every minute. Join me and my team of professional traders for unique perspectives and breakthrough investment opportunities.
* There is less that meets the eye in the U.S. stock market
* Market breadth has a foul odor, the average stock is falling, crude oil and interest rates are rising and complacency reigns…
The quote “there’s not much there there” comes from Gertrude Stein’s book Everybody’s Autobiography written about 90 years ago. The phrase conveys that a place, person or situation lacks substance or death and originated from Stein’s reflections about her childhood neighborhood in Oakland, California. It was Stein’s feeling that the area had changed dramatically with the familiar landmarks and very essence of her youth gone (leaving a sense of emptiness and loss). Stein believed that time and development erased the “there” of her childhood city.
At 5:30 AM S&P futures are -39 handles.
More interestingly is that Nasdaq futures are -310 handles — with, an infrequent occurrence that memory/semis AND hyperscalers are all falling down together.
A rejection by the president of an Iranian cease fire proposal has resulted in a +$3 rise in the price of crude oil.
For four months we have cautioned that the market ISNOT BROADENING OUT (despite a near-universal view on the part of the bullish cabal) and that market breadth is foul.
Importantly, several leading market sectors (e.g. financials/banks) are clearly rolling over — along with the Russell Index ($IWM) and the equal weighted S&P Index ($RSP):
VOLUME: friday's bounce came on decelerating volume and nasty trending breadth pic.twitter.com/lLpqojUEUT
The S&P 500 is 0.7% below a record high, yet 430 of those stocks are 21.7% below their highs. That means on average 86% of the stocks are in a bear market. Breadth has only been this bad twice, in January 1973 and in 1999/2000. On both occasions, the S&P then crashed nearly 50%
All day long the bulls are denying the validity of today’s decline.
The principal criticism they have is the strength in S&P EPS.
One month ago I debunked the argument that strong EPS means strong stock prices in this column (reposted in its entirety because it was an important one):
Debunking the Core Bullish Argument That Strong EPS Equates to Strong Price Gains
The investment mosaic is far more complicated than suggested by hosts, investment strategists, panelists and guests in the business media.
First-Level Thinking Vs Second-Level Thinking
Specifically, many distill the bullish argument to this: Since 2026 S&P EPS is expected to be about +20% (well above consensus expectations at the beginning of the year), the S&P price gains in 2026 should be about in line with that profit growth (or better). Candidly, that sort of distillation is the essence of “first-level thinking.”
First-level thinking is lazy, simplistic and superficial — it looks for simple formulas and easy answers. To paraphrase Howard Marks:
First-level thinking says, “S&P EPS growth will be strong, let’s buy the market.”
Second-level thinking says, “S&P EPS growth will be strong, but everyone knows it. Stocks are fairly or overpriced, let’s sell the market.”
Most recent examples of when S&P EPS was better than expected and strong were in 2018 (+20.5% EPS growth, -6.6% decline in the S&P), 2006 (+16.7% EPS growth, +11.3% rise in the S&P), 2005 (+19.3% EPS growth, +8.8% rise in the S&P) and 2004 (+20.1% EPS growth, +4.2% rise in the S&P).
Going back, during the last 50 years — other 12-month periods with robust EPS growth and less-than-stellar to down S&P price include the years 1993, 1992, 1987, 1984, 1979 and others.
S&P 500 Index
Source: Seabreeze Partners
Furthermore, I would argue that the backdrop of 2026-2027 offers unique market challenges relative to prior periods since 1975 (“it’s different this time”):
* High and rising inflation and interest rates.
* A burgeoning deficit and U.S. debtload may be a permanent condition giving the general lack of discipline from both parties in Washington DC.
* Improvisational geopolitical and fiscal policies that present threats to political and economic stability.
* Both parties are moving to extremes — the Republican party more to the right and the Democratic party to the left. With a possible Democratic congressional majority win in November, anti-corporate policy (higher corporate taxes, etc.) may be in the offing.
* Traditional valuation metrics in the 98%-tile and two standard deviations above the average.
* The AI capital spending spree and gains from investments have inflated S&P profit reports — as noted in my “More Tales From Nvidia” series an earnings reckoning may lie in the not too distant future.
Bottom Line
Looking at any one variable (e.g. S&P EPS growth) to forecast S&P price is fatuous, simplistic, lazy and is contradicted by past investment returns data.
Stated simply, the correlation between S&P EPS growth and S&P price gains is a crutch and is not a reliable indicator.
Historically, elevated consensus long-term earnings growth rates have been a contrarian indicator.
On the recent strength in cannabis stocks I am selling a portion of all my individual weed holdings and putting the proceeds into Green Thumb ($GTBIF), which has been lagging. Green Thumb is the company likely to attract the most institutional interest and is best of breed.
Moreover, on the announcement of rescheduling of cannabis I expect GTBIF to quickly seek a U.S. uplisting, making it eligible to be included in exchange-traded funds (just as what happened with Trulieve ($TRLV)).
Position: Long MSOS common (VL) and calls (S), GTBIF (M)