Boockvar on the Fed’s Yawner

From Peter Boockvar:

A yawner and what will Chair Warsh say?

The FOMC statement was a yawner as it was identical in its wording with the prior meeting on the economic commentary however there was one change of slight note and maybe a reference to the upcoming results from the economic data gathering piece of the task force.

The new line said right after the line “Inflation remains elevated” that “The accumulation of more information will help the Committee determine the policy stance appropriate to ensure a timely return of inflation to the Committee’s 2% goal.” I guess that is just stating the obvious.

We did get two dissents, one from Lisa Cook, a Governor, and the other from Beth Hammack who has dissented before, and assume all else equal, they’ll again argue for a rate increase in December.

With little to chew on here, bond yields are about unchanged with the 2 yr remaining at 4.77% vs 1:59pm est and the 10s and 30s each up 1 bp.

In yearning for more info about the Fed’s leanings as we now look to the December meeting, I’m sure again Chair Warsh will dance around making any commitment and we’ll be more reliant on the upcoming speeches and comments that his colleagues give.

Position: None

An Ever More Blunt Tool

The Federal Reserve’s interest rate policy is, increasingly, an ever more blunt tool.

Why don’t market participants and “talking heads” understand this?

Position: None  

FOMC Holds Rates Steady; Governor Cook Dissents

As expected by most, the Fed held rates unchanged this afternoon, reiterating their commitment to bringing down inflation, but not offering a clear signal on December.

The statement remained short but upgraded the assessment of the economy to a “strong pace” from a “solid” one in September.

The committee went on to say that the the “accumulation of more information will help the committee determine the policy stance appropriate to ensure a timely return of inflation to the committee’s 2% goal.”

There was one big surprise, though. I mentioned in my preview there would likely be dissents, particularly from Cleveland Fed President Hammack, who did dissent, but there was also a dissent from Governor Lisa Cook, her first dissent since becoming a Board member in 2022. As you may recall, President Trump has recently renewed efforts to remove Cook from the Fed, following an earlier effort blocked by the Supreme Court.

From the press conference

Warsh starts on economic growth, noting the strong numbers fueled by consumer spending and business investment. Unemployment rate down from a year ago. Says later that the investment boom is “broadening”.

“Not willing to call financial conditions tight” but they have moved “in the direction of achieving a longer and more durable period of economic growth”.

There will be eight meetings next year, but one will focus “exclusively on broad monetary policy strategy with neither a vote on the Federal Funds rate nor a policy statement anticipated” and sees that growing to two meetings on strategy and six on policy in 2028.

Interesting moment at the presser: before answering a question from Colby Smith of The New York Times, Warsh said, “I have been reading your stories this week.” Smith was seen by some as an outlet the Fed used to signal coming moves during blackout periods when she covered the Fed for the Financial Times. The remark could raise her standing as a potential “Fed whisperer,” a title long held by The Wall Street Journal’s Nick Timiraos. Timiraos seems to have lost some favor after his report that Governor Waller wasn’t a fan of Warsh’s task forces which drew harsh criticism from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent.

Warsh on the impact of interest rates on the AI buildout: “On the thrust of your question of — with respect to the new technology and this investment surge — do interest rates matter? I believe they do. And I don’t believe that they’re somehow divorced from the rest of the economy.”

Post-FOMC rate hike expectations are little changed:

  • December: the odds of a hike are 83%, from 84% yesterday.
  • Hikes priced by Dec ‘26: +21bps (about 0.8 hikes), from +22bps.
  • Hikes priced by Dec ‘27: +74bps (about 3.0 hikes), from +75bps.

Things I Did Today

Here are today’s things:

* I added to my $SPY at $771.44 and $QQQ at $728.34 shorts. 

* I added to $MSOX at $1.86, $VRNO at $5.06 and $GLAS at $2.23. 

Position: Long MSOX (S), VRNO (VS), GLAS (S); Short SPY (M), QQQ (VS)

Subscribers and I Talk About the Fed’s Short-Term Market Impact

mikash999

Doug, if the Fed stands pat today as you expect, could that initially encourage an equity rally even as it further undermines the Fed’s inflation-fighting credibility? Or, with a hold already largely priced in, would the greater risk be a bond-market selloff and higher long-term yields that ultimately pressure stocks? Curious which reaction you think would dominate—and whether the initial response would hold.

dennissong

I’ve been thinking this through as well.   If it’s priced in, why would the bond market selloff?  Would that surprise anyone if they held? So it should come down to presser.   Feeling like the battle of the wits here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EkBuKQEkio

Dougie Kass

i have no clue.

I think no increase is built into prices and the after hours EPS releases from two hyperscalers holds more weight than the Fed.